Editor's note: Immigrant bashing across the nation is de rigueur, and much of the debate is originating in Colorado. Former Gov. Richard Lamm has risen to national prominence for his warnings that legal and illegal immigration from south of the border threatens the future of the country. Colorado Congressman Tom Tancredo has threatened to launch a presidential bid steeped in an anti-immigration platform if the current administration doesn't get tougher on increased border militarization. Last month, vigilantes calling themselves "Minutemen" staged a media circus along the Arizona-Mexico border to spotlight their fears of an immigrant "invasion."
This week, the Independent offers a package of stories that explore the social implications and realities of life along the border. Through the lens of a renowned photographer, a spate of lawsuits involving a militant family and the volunteerism of Colorado College students, we glimpse this complex and increasingly prominent issue.
Twenty-five years ago, when the border was more porous and the times less perilous, the U.S. Border Patrol actually allowed Mexican kids to cross to the other side, to play in the green fields of America.
At least they did in San Ysidro, Calif., north of Tijuana, where the border fence was hardly worth mentioning. The Mexican kids lived in shacks in crowded Tijuana, their houses perched in dense clusters on hillsides. But at the bottom of the slope, the town ended abruptly and gave way to the rolling green hills of California. It was a simple matter for kids to slip north, and one day in 1979, a couple of young boys ran onto the American slopes to fly a red and black kite.
Photographer Alex Webb captured that odd border moment, when some kids' need for open space temporarily overrode international politics. In his picture, "San Ysidro, California, 1979," the kids frolic on the green grass, their sense of liberty palpable. Their kite soars above both nations -- high over the houses of Mexico and the hills of California -- heading, you hope, for the open atmosphere.
Those kinds of escapes happen far less frequently nowadays, since the "U.S. government has built up the fence into a massive metal wall," as Webb writes in his book Crossings: Photographs From the U.S.-Mexico Border (Monacelli Press, 2003), a sumptuous volume of pictures he took over a 26-year period, from 1975 to 2001. Webb is a Magnum photographer, shooting for the well-known agency that chronicles world events. A major show of his pictures, organized by the Museum of Contemporary Art San Diego, is making its way around the country, a prelude to a European tour.
"I've noticed big changes in the border over the years," said Webb in a recent phone interview from his Brooklyn home.
"What happens near the fence is different. When I started working on the border, on up through 1995, it was pretty easy to cross, through Tijuana, San Ysidro, Juarez. In Tijuana, huge numbers of people would gather on the border and rush through during the shift changes of the Border Patrol."
Dashing to the other side
The border winds its way across the North American terrain for 1,952 miles, from the Pacific coast of California, clear past Arizona and New Mexico, and on to Texas, where it ends at the Gulf of Mexico. Returning intermittently to the border over more than two decades -- in between trips to Istanbul, the Amazon, Florida and war-torn Haiti and Uganda -- Webb has pointed his Leica at points all along the frontera, including the Arizona border towns of Nogales, Naco and Agua Prieta.
Vendors used to sell tacos along the line to prospective migrants, Webb said, and in some towns, Mexicans would actually get their mail on the American side.
"For years, there was a kind of casualness that's disappeared. Around '95, the effort to beef up border security began."
Webb's pictures record some of those changes. A photo taken in Tijuana in 1992 shows a long line of men on the Mexican side, awaiting that serendipitous Border Patrol shift change. They stand patiently on a low concrete wall, looking north, ready to dash at the right moment al otro lado, to the other side. But this casual wink-wink arrangement came to a halt when the feds cracked down on illegal immigration in the mid-'90s, sealing off the borders in the big cities and forcing migrants into far more dangerous desert treks.
Harsh corrugated metal fences went up, slicing through towns like Nogales, El Paso and San Diego. Once the metal swathes were used as military landing flats in the Vietnam and Persian Gulf wars; now they split twin border cities in two. Webb's images switch from the shadowy cat-and-mouse games of earlier years to glimpses of the forbidding border metal. A 1995 picture from Tijuana shows the metal barrier planted on the Pacific beach, stretching way out to sea, the better to discourage enterprising swimmers.
One of the last photos in the project, "Agua Prieta, Sonora/Douglas, Arizona, 2001," shows migrants stealthily trying to cross into Arizona. When it was taken in 2001, Agua Prieta was still the hot crossing. In the picture, the migrants crouch as they make their way past some wooden fence posts, trying to slip under the Border Patrol's radar.
A high level of patience
For all his attention to the tragedies of the border, where the poorest of the Earth's poor come up against the military hardware of the Earth's mightiest nation, Webb's pictures are never purely photojournalistic.
"I'm a street photographer who deals with social issues, not a journalist," Webb said. He doesn't normally travel with the media pack. He wouldn't have turned up, he said, in Tombstone, Ariz., last month to record the sudden influx of vigilantes to the Wild West town, where photographers and reporters seemed to outnumber the self-styled "Minutemen."
"An awful lot of what I do is wandering ... letting the experience lead you where it will. I have a deep faith that something will work out."
Like Henri Cartier-Bresson, the founder of the legendary photo agency Magnum, Webb has a gift for capturing the "decisive moment." His work is fraught with elusive narratives and quirky but impossibly apt images.
Webb never stages his pictures or manipulates his subjects.
"That would make a mockery of what I do," witnessing history, he said. Instead, he wanders. And he waits. And he shoots endlessly.
"I shoot 1,500 to 2,000 rolls of film a year, and I come away with maybe 15 pictures," he said. "There's a high level of frustration in this kind of work. Ultimately, you have to have a high level of patience.
"It's mysterious how pictures happen. Every once in a while, it works."
His openness to experience -- and patience -- is what allows him to get shots like "Nogales, Sonora, 1995," a picture of the classic Mexican tan dog scrounging beneath a bright red banner at the exact moment that a woman in a red dress strolls past the hillside homes.
The place demanded color
California-born, in 1952, Boston-raised and Harvard-educated, Webb first learned photography from his father. As a teenager, he worked on a high school film project, and the group experience persuaded him that he was more suited to the solitary profession of photography.
"I realized I wanted to work alone."
In college, he studied literature and history, disciplines that would later offer him insights in his travels around the globe.
"Lots of things I studied at Harvard were useful," he said. "I took a big survey course in the history of revolutions. While I was witnessing the terror in Haiti in 1987, I thought of the terror in the French Revolution."
By the time he graduated, he had already published two photography projects, one of street kids in Cambridge and another of the "strange Americana" on Route 1 north of Boston. Magnum snapped him up right away.
One year in, Webb found himself on the U.S.-Mexico border, partly inspired by a Graham Greene short story.
"In the mythology of the U.S., the border has always had a certain allure," he said. "I took a trip in 1975, when I was just becoming a photojournalist."
The early pictures were in black and white, then the only palette for serious photographers. But he soon found that the place demanded color.
"In the places I seem to be drawn to, color is embedded in the culture," he said. "I started color in '78 or '79."
Webb kept coming back to the border, even when other assignments and projects took him all over the world. He was at first more interested in the literal border crossings, the world of the illegal migrants. But he gradually began to focus on "many other kinds of crossings," the way the two nations sidle up and slide into one another, alternately colliding and collaborating.
There's a "sense of a world that's not really Mexico, not really the U.S. It's something in between."
He was arrested a couple of times, he said, when he was traveling with undocumented immigrants, but each time, once he provided his journalism credentials, he was readily released. The only time he felt himself in danger: "I was crossing illegally with another photographer. We were approached by some guys -- they were probably bandits. There was some tension. Considering the number of people crossing illegally, I find it a remarkably nonviolent place."
Drawn to cultural conflict
Webb has photographed in a few very violent places -- in the Haiti uprising, in a coup in Uganda and in the Palestinian-Israeli conflict -- but he prefers not to. He has no interest in being embedded in Iraq, for instance, where the danger is so great, journalists can hardly travel anywhere without a military escort.
"Some photographers are drawn to civil strife. Not me. I'm drawn to places in cultural conflict."
Despite all his years of witness along the U.S.-Mexico border, Webb said, "I don't have any solutions" to its problems. "I'm just a photographer. Obviously you can't just let anyone come in. But the economy of the Southwest just wouldn't exist without cheap labor. What would a pepper cost in New York [without migrant labor]? It's an insoluble problem, like many situations in the world."
Case in point is Webb's 1979 picture of migrants being arrested by the Border Patrol in San Ysidro. It could have been taken yesterday. A helicopter hovers overhead under thickening clouds. Below, in a field of lovely yellow flowers, two men raise their arms to be frisked by the agents, but the gesture has a Christlike air of innocence and resignation.
Veering between tragedy and beauty, like the border itself, the picture begs the question, "What terrible economic situation drives people from their homes?" Webb said. It's set in a landscape of "incredible beauty," but documents something "totally tragic.
"I don't have answers, but as a photographer, I try to respond to a world that's both tragic and comic."
Helen Collins is the polar opposite of Jill Gaebler and Richard Skorman. I'm ready for…
Glad to see the Utilities workers endorse Gaebler and Skorman. I would add Helen Collins…
Well the Work Force Center at least gave someone a high paying job. What is…