Best Of 2012: IndyPick • Pizza Above 9,500 Feet
It's easy to miss Dirty Sally's bar in downtown Victor, with no sign marking its presence except one in the window. But the loyal locals know all about it. The menu includes calzones and other sandwiches, but Lori and Bill Phelan's pizza stands up to anything in the big city. Cooked in a top-notch, wood-fired oven and with ample sauce, cheese and toppings, the crust and flavor will blow you away. Prices are reasonable: $12.95 gets you a 14-inch pizza with meat and two veggies, and gluten-free options are available, as are Bristol beers in bottles. What's not to like? — Ralph Routon