Colorado Springs Independent
Friday, September 5, 2008 :   Last Update: 5:09am
Home » Opinions » Public Eye


'Merry Christmas' -- or else

By CARA DEGETTE

Father Christmas: Pastor Jim Hagan had an epiphany 10 
years ago, and his idea has since spread nationwide.
_
Father Christmas: Pastor Jim Hagan had an epiphany 10 years ago, and his idea has since spread nationwide.
Collan Fitzpatrick

All the great social movements of our time, it seems, start right here in Colorado Springs. The campaign to ban gays and lesbians from seeking legal protection. The battle to eradicate all taxes. The crusade to pray to Jesus in a football locker room.

The latest, of course, is the war over Christmas, an idea that actually was born at the Chapel Hills Mall in Colorado Springs 10 years ago. That's when Pastor Jim Hagan of Friendship Assembly of God Church went shopping and had an epiphany. The red and green decorations were everywhere, but Hagan got upset when store clerks did not respond in kind to his wish of "Merry Christmas."

So Hagan took out a quarter-page advertisement in the Gazette. The message was clear: If companies and shop owners didn't clean up their act, Hagan promised, they would be faced with a boycott.

"We will be monitoring," warned the ad. "Should we, who consider ourselves Christians, spend our money at places that feel 'Christmas' is offensive? Aren't those retail stores offending us -- the majority -- by promoting Christmas spending but denying the origin and reason for Christmas ... Christ?

"After 2,000 years, have we still not found room for Him at the inn?"

The local shopping boycott never really panned out. At the time, the Rev. Stephen Todd, then the president of the Colorado Springs Association of Evangelicals, shared his take. "With all the culture wars to fight about, that would be one I would probably be a conscientious objector to," he said. "That's just not a hill I would choose to die on."

Flash forward 10 years. Hagan truly has established himself as a man ahead of his time. The "Say 'Merry Christmas' or else" crowd has grown into a national, litigious army. "I did, at least, see it on the horizon," says Hagan, modestly. "I was thinking about rerunning my ad [this year], and saying 'Remember 1995? Is this prophetic, or what?'"

This year, the very famous Rev. Jerry Falwell launched his "Friend or Foe Christmas Campaign," urging pastors across the country to buy full-page ads in their community newspapers announcing that "Christmas is still legal." Falwell also has a battalion of 750 lawyers, ready to provide free assistance to those who are facing persecution.

Meanwhile, the Tupelo, Miss.-based American Family Association is calling for boycotts of stores that refuse to properly recognize that Jesus is the reason.

Not to be outdone, the Alliance Defense Fund, a conservative legal firm founded in part by Colorado Springs-based Focus on the Family president James Dobson, has announced its own campaign -- and even trademarked it. The Christmas Project' has a slogan: "Merry Christmas. It's okay to say it," and has 800 lawyers at the ready to go after anyone who challenges the rights to "sing Christmas carols at school," "pass out candy canes to classmates," "call it 'Christmas vacation,'" "sponsor a nativity scene on public property" and, of course, "say 'Merry Christmas.'"

Unconfirmed tales of egregious infractions abound: children in Plano, Texas ordered not to wear the colors green and red to school; children in Seattle having their lunch menus reprinted to read "Happy Holidays," school officials in Dodgeville, Wis., altering the carol "Silent Night" to be sung as "Cold in the Night."

The governor of Georgia, Sonny Perdue, became an instant hero when he announced that he would be lighting a "Christmas" -- not "holiday" -- tree. And George W. Bush got a knuckle sandwich for sending out White House cards that read, "Happy Holidays."

Here in Colorado Springs, newly elected School District 49 board member Anna Bartha established her focus-on-education creds by introducing an edict to change "winter break" to "Christmas break." Glad to hear things are so rosy in D-49 that the biggest issue is semantics.

There still are some voices of reason. In a recent letter to the Gazette, Father Bill Carmody of Holy Family Catholic Church pointed out that saying "Happy Holidays" is not all that bad. After all, the word "Holiday" is a derivative of "Holy Day," and thus, should not be uttered lightly.

And then there is the Rev. Barry Lynn, executive director of the Washington D.C.-based Americans United for Separation of Church and State. In an open letter to Falwell, Lynn this month made a startling announcement: "There is no 'war on Christmas!'"

"Even as I write this, millions of Americans are erecting Christmas trees and nativity scenes at their homes, and thousands of churches are planning special Christmas services," Lynn wrote.

"I am deeply disappointed that you have chosen a time that Christians observe as a season of peace and good will and turned it into a time of religious divisiveness and community conflict. Your 'Friend or Foe' campaign may be great for fundraising and publicity, but it has sown discord unnecessarily."

Lynn goes on to point out how, after he debated Falwell on Fox News Channel's "O'Reilly Factor," Lynn received dozens of nasty e-mails, including the following message: "Hope you die soon. Merry Christmas."

And it all started right here, at the Chapel Hills Mall in li'l old Colorado Springs.

Kinda makes ya weepy thinking about it.

-- degette@csindy.com

COMMENTS
4 comments posted for this article
Mia  7/22/2008 - 9:20am
   Seems like people should have bigger fish to fry. In a multicultural world, saying "happy holidays" recognizes that not everyone celebrates Christmas. If you're not sure, say happy holidays what's the big deal?
   
   As for a holiday tree vs. a Christmas tree, that's ridiculous. It's a Christmas tree, the other religions don't use trees so there's no reason to call it something it isn't.
   
   Honestly, people, do a little traveling, get out of the house a little more. There's a whole world out there.
Report this comment
Taz, Out-of-Town  7/22/2008 - 5:17pm
   "There still are some voices of reason."
   
   Seems to me that the writer's take is that you can take on any cause you want and be "reasonable" but take on a Christian cause - and suddenly you've lost your reasonable-ness.
   
   It's not "unreasonable" to acknowledge that the "Happy Holidays" in North America are in fact a Christian tradition - a tradition that celebrates the birth of Jesus. As "religious" as it is, it is the "reason for the season". Is it "reasonable" to massage it into something else?
   
   Celebrate the Christmas season for what it is: a celebration of the birth of Jesus. Just like respecting Hanukah or Ramadan, it is only reasonable.
   
   Taz
Report this comment
mom2princessm, Central  7/23/2008 - 8:50am
   I have worked in the customer service industry for over 20 years. Long before their were "political" reasons for saying "Happy Holidays" instead of "Merry Christmas" I used Happy Holidays. Why?
   Definetley not because I was afraid or ashamed to give Christ the recognition and praise he deserved. Instead it was because it allowed me to wish people a joyous holiday season, from Thanksgiving to New Year, without offending any who might celebrate the holidays differantly than I did.
   I still say Happy Holidays to everyone I meet in November & December and I will continue to do so regardless of how the debate turns out.
   Seems to me the true measure of a Christian is allowing others their beliefs and leading by example. Not by threatening the livlyhood of hard working employees who are trying to spread holiday cheer within the limits imposed by companies who are trying to avoid exactly the reaction from non-religious groups that the religious groups are threatening.
Report this comment
Mister Mxyzptlk, North End  7/23/2008 - 8:58pm
   So what if a cross cultist refuses to shop at a store because the employees say "Happy Holidays" instead of "Merry Christmas". How many idiots can these groups actually claim to have in their ranks? How many of these wacky religious fanatics are going to bother keeping a list of the banned stores on them when they go into the malls for the REAL reason for the season. Shopping for costly gifts to prove your love to all your friends and family.
   
   We don't shop anywhere for christmas, other than Wal Mart. We get the ingredients for home made candy and some pretty containers to pack the candy in. I think it says more about how you value someone to give them a sweet treat made in your own kitchen than a pointless trinket that will be lost withing a few months anyhow.
   
   I think it's hilarious that the cross cultists are concerned about what employees say during the festival of greed and avarice that is the holiday season. It's like worrying about what song the band is playing while your cruise ship is sinking into the ocean.
Report this comment



ALSO BY CARA DEGETTE
See you in the pixel papers
One of the Independent's founders says farewell after 15 years in the Public Eye. [April 24, 2008]
Forcing Hope where there is none
So much for local control, D-11 discovers. [April 17, 2008]
Beware of outsiders
A millionaire with no Colorado ties is sponsoring an amendment to obliterate the state's last vestiges of affirmative action. [April 10, 2008]

2008 Annual Manual - Digital Edition
Click here to see the 2008 Annual Manual: Digital Edition


Read our
weekly newsletter



Submit an Event Listing!

Job Openings & Internships